Online ClosingsFixed Closing Cost $999*

Ontario Code of Ethics Misrepresentation Duty

Trust in Real Estate Services Act Ontario Code of Ethics misrepresentation duty issues can arise alongside the contractual duty of good faith real estate parties owe after they sign an Agreement of Purchase and Sale. In Ontario, buyers and sellers must perform their contract honestly and cannot deliberately undermine its performance, but they may still protect their own interests and bargain firmly before a deal is made.

Good faith in Ontario real estate: the short answer

Good faith in Ontario real estate means that, once an Agreement of Purchase and Sale is in place, each party must perform its contractual obligations honestly and must not deliberately defeat the deal. It does not mean that a buyer must accept every defect, that a seller must accept every demand, or that either side must give the other a free exit from a signed agreement.

Before acceptance, a buyer may negotiate price, conditions, closing date and inclusions aggressively, and a seller may reject an offer or seek better terms. After acceptance, the signed agreement, its conditions, deadlines and notice provisions govern. For a closer look at the document itself, read our article on an Ontario purchase agreement.

What good faith in contract and the duty of honesty mean

What is good faith in contract? It is an organizing principle of Canadian contract law that informs specific duties, including the duty not to lie or knowingly mislead another party about matters directly connected to performance of the contract.

In Bhasin v. Hrynew, 2014 SCC 71, the Supreme Court of Canada recognized a general duty of honest contractual performance. The duty of honesty does not generally make the parties fiduciaries, require them to put the other side first, or create a broad duty to disclose every fact that could influence the bargain.

In plain language, the in good faith legal meaning is narrower than “be nice” and broader than “do not commit fraud.” A party cannot say something it knows is false, or knowingly allow the other party to proceed on a mistaken understanding about performance where the law requires correction.

The three good-faith duties that matter in a purchase or sale

Three related duties most often matter in a real estate dispute: honest performance, good-faith exercise of contractual discretion, and co-operation needed to carry out the agreement. Their application depends on the exact wording of the APS and the facts of the transaction.

  1. Honest performance: do not lie or knowingly mislead about a step required to close, such as whether documents have been sent, access has been arranged, or a required payment has been made.
  2. Contractual discretion: where an agreement gives one party a decision-making power, it must be exercised in a manner connected to the purpose for which that power was granted. Wastech Services Ltd. v. Greater Vancouver Sewerage and Drainage District, 2021 SCC 7 explains that good faith does not rewrite the bargain or require a party to surrender its legitimate contractual interests.
  3. Co-operation: each party must take the steps contemplated by the agreement that are necessary to achieve its purpose. This principle is illustrated by Dynamic Transport Ltd. v. O.K. Detailing Ltd., where a party could not rely on a condition it had prevented from being fulfilled.

For example, consider a buyer purchasing a $925,000 Toronto condominium with a financing condition that expires at 9:00 p.m. three business days after acceptance. The buyer should review the condition’s wording, submit the requested mortgage material promptly, and keep records of the lender’s response. If the clause requires the buyer’s satisfaction, the scope of that discretion still turns on the clause and the duty of good faith; it is not automatically a licence to use an unrelated reason dishonestly.

Buyers: conditions, deposits, and honest performance

A buyer may terminate under a financing, inspection, sale-of-property or other condition only in accordance with that condition’s wording and deadline. Some conditions require reasonable efforts, some are framed around the buyer’s satisfaction, and some impose specific notice requirements, so a buyer should not assume the same rule applies to every offer.

Read the condition with the rest of the APS: identify who may waive it, whether written notice is required, and what happens if notice is not delivered in time. Keep lender emails, inspection reports, listing information, notices and proof of delivery. Before serving a waiver or termination notice, a property contract lawyer can review the language and the proposed notice.

A “good faith payment” is not a defined Ontario real estate term. In many conversations, it means the deposit paid under the APS, which is commonly held in trust pending completion, release, settlement or a legal determination. A deposit dispute should not be resolved by one party simply demanding the funds from the brokerage or other stakeholder.

For example, a buyer agrees to pay a $45,000 deposit within 24 hours and makes the payment on time, but later discovers an inspection concern before the inspection-condition deadline. The buyer’s right to terminate depends on the actual inspection condition and proper notice, not simply on the size of the deposit or an informal explanation given after the deadline.

Sellers: co-operation, information, and closing obligations

A seller must comply with the APS and must not create or exploit a closing problem that prevents the buyer from performing. That can include providing agreed access, giving usable deposit instructions, responding through the proper closing process to title requisitions, and delivering the documents required on closing.

A seller need not volunteer every fact about the property merely because an offer has been accepted. However, a seller should not make a false statement, knowingly mislead the buyer about a performance-related matter, or obstruct a contractual step and later claim the buyer defaulted because that step did not occur.

For example, if an APS for a $1.4 million detached home gives the buyer an inspection-access right, the seller should not refuse the arranged inspection without a contractual basis and then insist that the buyer’s condition lapse. If a deposit deadline, amendment, or closing date becomes contentious, the parties should follow the APS notice provisions rather than rely on a hurried text message.

When silence becomes dishonesty—and when it does not

Silence can breach the duty of honest performance where a party knowingly allows the other side to remain under a mistaken understanding about a matter directly linked to contractual performance. In C.M. Callow Inc. v. Zollinger, 2020 SCC 45, the Supreme Court explained that a party may have to correct a false impression it has created or knowingly allowed to persist in that setting.

This is not a general rule that every seller must disclose every potentially relevant fact before a contract is signed. Whether a non-disclosure creates liability may instead raise misrepresentation, latent-defect, agency, statutory or other legal issues. The timing, what was said, what each party knew, and the APS terms matter.

Real estate agents: honesty, good faith, and misrepresentation duties

Ontario registrants are regulated under the Trust in Real Estate Services Act, 2020 and its Code of Ethics, while buyers and sellers remain responsible for their own contractual obligations. A registrant’s professional duties are not identical to a buyer’s or seller’s duty of honest performance under an APS.

Clients should carefully review every offer, sign-back, amendment and condition before acceptance, particularly where property information, representations, deposit terms or deadlines change. An oral promise can create a serious dispute and may sometimes be enforceable, but written terms provide much clearer evidence of what was agreed.

Misrepresentation is also distinct from ordinary bad faith. A claim may arise from a false statement or, in some circumstances, a failure to disclose information where there was a duty to disclose; fraudulent and negligent misrepresentation have different legal requirements and potential remedies.

What happens when a party acts in bad faith

A party that breaches the duty of honest performance or another good-faith obligation may face a breach-of-contract claim. Possible remedies include damages and, in appropriate cases, specific performance, but neither remedy is automatic.

A claimant generally needs evidence of the breach, a causal connection between the breach and the claimed loss, and proof of the amount of loss. This can include the signed APS, correspondence, replacement-sale documents, invoices, financing records, appraisal evidence and proof of additional carrying costs. Deposit consequences likewise depend on the APS, the alleged breach, any release, and the facts.

These disputes may be litigated in the Ontario Superior Court of Justice, but early legal assessment can also clarify whether completion, an extension, a negotiated release, or another response is appropriate. If your house sale fell through last minute, preserve the record before taking a position on fault.

What to do when a real estate deal is going off track

Act promptly and preserve the written record when the other party threatens termination, misses a deadline, or will not co-operate before closing. Do not unilaterally terminate the APS or authorize release of a deposit without advice on the agreement and the notice provisions.

  • Save the signed APS, all schedules, amendments, waivers and notices.
  • Create a timeline of acceptance, deposit, condition, requisition and closing deadlines.
  • Keep emails, texts, brokerage communications, proof of delivery and deposit records.
  • Keep evidence supporting your position, such as lender correspondence, inspection reports, access requests, quotes and receipts.
  • Ask counsel to assess any notice before responding, particularly close to a condition or closing deadline.

A closing lawyer in Toronto can assess the APS, the available options and the steps needed to protect your position while the transaction is still capable of being completed.

FAQ: good faith in Ontario real estate

What is a good faith payment?

In Ontario real estate, “good faith payment” usually refers informally to the APS deposit. Ask who holds it in trust, when it is due, and what the agreement says about its release, rather than relying on the label alone.

Can an oral promise matter?

Yes, an oral promise can matter and may lead to a dispute over whether it is enforceable. Put important changes in a written amendment signed by the necessary parties, and obtain legal advice before relying on a verbal assurance that conflicts with the APS.

What is honesty in real estate?

For buyers and sellers, honesty real estate generally means not lying or knowingly misleading about contractual performance. For registrants, professional conduct duties under Ontario’s real estate regulatory framework may also apply, while misrepresentation claims depend on their own facts and legal elements.

Related articles

Speak with a Toronto real estate lawyer

Early advice can help you assess a condition, deposit issue, threatened termination or closing dispute before a deadline passes or a position becomes harder to protect.

Call 416-321-8766 or request a quote to discuss your matter with Zinati Kay.